黑料天堂

Journalism from the 黑料天堂
Context is no longer producing new reporting, but this site will remain as an archive.

'Rotten buildings': Corruption in spotlight after Turkey quake

People sit and stand near a collapsed building, in the aftermath of the deadly earthquake, in Adiyaman, Turkey, February 12, 2023

People sit and stand near a collapsed building, in the aftermath of the deadly earthquake, in Adiyaman, Turkey, February 12, 2023. REUTERS/Sertac Kayar

What鈥檚 the context?

The death toll in Turkey's worst earthquake in modern history is fueling longstanding criticism about lax enforcement of construction regulations

  • Death toll in Turkey-Syria earthquake exceeds 37,000
  • Turkish opposition cites weak building controls, graft
  • Government orders arrests, meticulous investigation
  • Erdo臒an's party oversaw rapid construction boom

As rescuers race to find survivors in the rubble a week after Turkey's deadliest earthquake in a generation, anger is growing over why so many buildings collapsed and crumbled to the ground.

President Recep Tayyip Erdo臒an's government has vowed to meticulously investigate anyone suspected of responsibility for the collapse of buildings, of more than 100 suspects so far.

But Erdo臒an's critics accuse his government of failing to enforce building regulations, fuelling corruption, and of misspending special taxes levied after the last big quake in 1999 in order to make buildings more resistant.

White Helmets members rest on day five of the rescue operations after a massive earthquake in Jandaris, Syria February 10, 2023 in this image obtained from social media. White Helmets via REUTERS
Go DeeperTurkey earthquake: Four ways tech is being used to help victims
A student leaving for the United States at Jinnah International Airport, Karachi, Pakistan, on January 21, 2023
Go DeeperYoung professionals flee crisis-hit Pakistan in search of jobs
Almost one year on from devastating floods social housing lies empty after works were frozen in Limbourg, Belgium
Go DeeperFloods haunt Belgian town as rebuild seeks to stop repeat disaster

"The murderer is not the earthquake, but ... those who turn the cities into mass graves in the name of urban transformation, those whose signatures are at the bottom of every building approval," columnist Feray Aytekin Aydo臒an wrote in the left-wing BirGün newspaper last week.

Environment Minister Murat Kurum said 24,921 buildings across the region had collapsed or were heavily damaged in the 7.8-magnitude quake, based on assessments of more than 170,000 buildings.

The combined death toll from the disaster, which hit parts of Syria and Turkey, rose above 37,000 on Monday and looked set .

For many Turks who have lived through past earthquakes, there is a depressing sense of déjà vu.

After the 1999 quake, which killed more than 18,000 people in the northwest, building regulations - and corruption - were also widely blamed for exacerbating the disaster.

"Once again rotten buildings, once again thieving unscrupulous building contractors," one major Turkish newspaper said at the time.

It is common for developers to skirt planning regulations and critics say corrupt politicians and local officials often benefit by turning a blind eye to violations.

In the 10 years to 2022, amid a rapid boom in construction in Turkey, the country slipped 47 places in Transparency International's Corruption Perception Index to 101, having been as high as 54 out of 174 countries in 2012.

Erdo臒an's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment by Context.

A man walks past a damaged building in the aftermath of a deadly earthquake in Kahramanmaras, Turkey February 13, 2023

A man walks past a damaged building in the aftermath of a deadly earthquake in Kahramanmaras, Turkey February 13, 2023. REUTERS/Suhaib Salem

A man walks past a damaged building in the aftermath of a deadly earthquake in Kahramanmaras, Turkey February 13, 2023. REUTERS/Suhaib Salem

Clean start?

Public anger and economic problems, partly caused by the 1999 quake, helped catapult Erdo臒an's AK Party into power in 2002, promising a clean start free from the endemic corruption of the past.

The party embarked on a programme of massive infrastructure projects - new airports, ports, roads, railways and public housing projects sprang up across the country, contributing to Turkey's significant economic success.

"Construction was one of the pillars of the economic boom of Turkey in the first 10-12 years of the AK Party," said Wolfgango Piccoli, director of research at consultancy firm, Teneo, citing the party's "close connection" with the construction industry.

The rapid infrastructure growth won praise from foreign investors.

"It's one of the things we have celebrated – their ability to do infrastructure very quickly, but actually maybe too quickly with hindsight," said Timothy Ash, a Turkey analyst at BlueBay Asset Management.

"The reasons are all the expected ones, cost-cutting, greed, there's no other way to explain it. You have a culture of going for growth at all costs," he said.

Opposition politicians accuse the government of institutionalising what Turks call the "rentier system", a circular funding model in which friendly contractors are awarded lucrative state contracts in exchange for political and financial support.

"This collapse is the result of systematic rentier politics," opposition party leader Kemal K谋l谋çdaro臒lu said in a statement after visiting quake-affected cities in the south.

Erdo臒an has accused opponents of trying to exploit the situation for political purposes and of failing to face up to corruption in opposition-run municipalities that were also hard-hit by the disaster.

Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan meets with people in the aftermath of a deadly earthquake in Kahramanmaras, Turkey February 8, 2023

Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan meets with people in the aftermath of a deadly earthquake in Kahramanmaras, Turkey February 8, 2023. Murat Cetinmuhurdar/Presidential Press Office/Handout via REUTERS

Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan meets with people in the aftermath of a deadly earthquake in Kahramanmaras, Turkey February 8, 2023. Murat Cetinmuhurdar/Presidential Press Office/Handout via REUTERS

Regulations and amnesties

In 2007, the government passed new regulations aimed at cleaning up the construction sector, seeking to make new buildings earthquake-proof and shore up the old ones.

Planning rules have been further tightened since, most recently in 2018, requiring more steel columns and beams to absorb the impact of earthquakes.

But during the same year, the government issued an amnesty for existing buildings that had broken the rules - for a fee.

More than 10 million people applied, netting the state more than $3 billion in property taxes and registration fees.

More than half of Turkey's 13 million buildings contravene regulations, according to official data, making amnesties popular among property owners, as well as a lucrative source of government revenue.

Another amnesty was proposed last year and was making its way through parliament, despite criticism, even before the latest quake.

Marking the Aug. 17 anniversary of the 1999 quake last year, the Architects' Association said "anyone voting for a planning amnesty is responsible for incitement to murder".

The earthquake has handed Erdo臒an a huge rescue and reconstruction challenge in the run-up to an election scheduled for June that is already set to be of his two decades in power.

Any perception that the government is failing to address the disaster properly, or had not enforced adequate building codes, could hurt Erdo臒an's prospects in the vote, but some analysts say he could rally national support around the crisis response.

On a visit to the province of Hatay, one of the areas worst affected by the disaster, Erdo臒an pledged to activate all the building contractors working in public housing to clear the rubble and rebuild what had been lost within a year.

"We are a government that has proven ourselves on these issues," he said.

(Reporting by Jon Hemming in London. Editing by Helen Popper)


Context is powered by the 黑料天堂 Newsroom.

Our Standards:


Tags

  • Government aid
  • Housing
  • Economic inclusion
  • Corporate responsibility

Featured

President Donald Trump 2.0: What's next for the U.S.?

Our experienced correspondents around the United States and further afield examine how a Trump presidency affects climate change, reproductive rights, LGBTQ+ communities, immigration, socio-economic inclusion, and debates around Big Tech and AI. Here鈥檚 a round-up of our coverage so far.

Former U.S. President Donald Trump takes the stage to address supporters at a rally in West Palm Beach, Florida, U.S., November 6, 2024. REUTERS/Brian Snyder


The Backstory

New Tab IconThese links open on



Get 鈥楶olicy, honestly鈥 to learn how big decisions impact ordinary people.

By providing your email, you agree to our Privacy Policy.


Latest on Context

Footer, 黑料天堂 Logo

Context is a media platform created by the 黑料天堂. We provide news and analysis that contextualises how critical issues and events affect ordinary people, society and the environment.聽Find out more.

Our Products
  • Workforce Disclosure Initiative

    The Workforce Disclosure Initiative is an investor-backed project to improve the quantity & quality of corporate workforce data, via an annual survey & engagement process.

  • Trust Conference

    Trust Conference is the 黑料天堂鈥檚 flagship annual event, taking place in the heart of London each year.

  • TrustLaw

    TrustLaw is the 黑料天堂鈥檚 global pro bono service, facilitating free legal assistance to NGOs and social enterprises around the world.